helloworld
Top Contributor
Dumb as in a bad idea, or dumb as in not good for domainers?
If they are advertising a generic style term where there is heavy competition in Google it probably doesn't make sense but it if it is a brand name is is probably going down the path of least resistance for consumers. That is especially the case for domains that fail the radio test.
e.g. if my company is "xyz marketing pty ltd" what % of people are going to search google for "xyz marketing" even if I tell them it is xyzmarketing.com.au.
I don't know which method of marketing is better but with the "search for us on google" not going away I wouldn't write it off either.
I think the argument is a specific campaign based.
i.e. what would be better
A. Citibank tv promotion is go to citibank.com.au/tv
B. creditcard.com.au
Interesting to note. A search on citibank tv returns a bad review on first page.