My issue is not about the policy being wrong or right.
But while it is there, we need to comply.
Paul, you are right. In fact, everyone's pov is right.
In general, I agree with Jonathan's sentiments. Whilst there will always be a need for
some regulation, this policy is one of the most poorly drafted ones imho. I've posted about this before.
With the way this is worded, if you buy domain/s today - and then be seen to try and sell it / them the same day or shortly thereafter; you are technically contravening current policy.
You could be accused of buying for the "SOLE purpose" of buying for resale.
This isn't fair imho because this affects the business model of domainers. auDA knows we buy domains; and they know that invariably we are going to sell them. They accept that -
but yet this rule doesn't properly allow for that.
- auDA has this policy in place mainly to stop someone registering / purchasing a domain name that has relation or connection to another person / company / organisation (with a similar
company name or TM) - and then immediately offering this domain for sale to them. And that's fair enough imho.
So provided we don't do this,
we should be able to sell whenever we want - no waiting for a period of time to ensure we are "decent".
But the fact of the matter is (as johno69 says),
while the rule is there, we should be seen to be complying. If you know the location of a fixed speed camera, you'd be a bit silly going
past it at 200km/hour!
Anybody who goes out and immediately offers domains for sale
publicly (as in the same day or next day) is potentially asking for trouble from auDA. Why put yourself on their radar?
True, but aren't we the ones that can make change?
YES! But nothing changes quickly. It's like trying to stop and turn around a giant container ship.
You got to remember that it was worse previously. Until October last year, we had that dreaded "6 month rule" in place. I was part of the Secondary Market Working Group that helped get rid of it.
http://www.dntrade.com.au/secondary-market-working-group-t3698.html
Change will only happen if you / we make it happen. If you're not already a member of auDA; join. Put your hand up to take part in working groups and panels. Send letters to the Board.
Contact your "demand class" directors (via auDA office). A "squeaky door gets the oil"!
IMHO.